#109 ~ Immortal

Immortal by Traci L. Slatton

Immortal is a novel that sweeps through 150 years of Florentine history from Giotto to Leonardo da Vinci through the eyes of Luca Bastardo, whose first memories are of living in the street seemingly as an orphan.  What makes Luca different is that he does not perceptively age.  His long life did not start out pleasantly.  While living on the streets, he made a couple of friends.  His best friend ultimately sold him to a brothel owner who specialized in pedaling the flesh of young children.  The only way he survived over twenty years of sexual abuse was by traveling to the gorgeous churches around Florence and through his friendship with Gioto.  When Luca won his freedom from prostitution created a generations long family long vendetta against him.  The discovery of alchemy, his talent for medicine and the search for his true love are what give him purpose as he keeps one step ahead of the those who want to destroy him.

This is not an easy novel to read.  The scenes at the brothel and with Luca dealing with the plague were grueling.  For me, the hardest parts weren’t the most emotionally difficult, but were those dealing heavily with alchemy and with Leonardo da Vinci. Alchemy most definitely had its place in this novel.  Without it, Luca would never have foreseen and chose love over immortality.  Luca’s dream of creating gold, however, felt hollow to me.  I liked the way that played out, but that didn’t change my opinion that his interest in it was half-hearted.  I also found Leonardo a difficult character to enjoy.  He was much more than a precociuos child.  I found his questions much too pointed and advanced for his age, even if he was a genious.  Because of this, his character felt like a tool needed to move Luca along.

I finished this book over two weeks ago, but I’m still not sure how I feel about it.  It was a book that felt as long as its 528 pages.  The ending was amazing.  It was a tremendous payoff.  This wouldn’t have been dampened at all had the novel been pared down.  At the same time, I was left wanting more information about the time Luca spent exiled from Florence.  Despite my own ambivilence, this novel would be interesting to those who enjoy reading about Florence, art, and the Medici family.  Luca’s view of the city as it changed so drastically over his lifetime and certainly provides a unique view of the city.

The best part about reading this novel was discussing it with those of you who joined The Literate Housewive’s Book Club!  I enjoyed reading your posts and your reviews.  If you haven’t been back in a while, please post your review there so I can compile all of the reviews for the newsletter.  I’ve also posted a call for suggestions for the next book.  I’m really looking forward to doing this again.


To buy this book, click here.


  • At 2008.10.14 22:44, softdrink said:

    Off topic, but my book arrived today. Thank you!

    On topic…I’d love to read this one…someday. I think the 100+ books in my TBR pile would stage a revolt if I bought this one.
    You’re welcome about the book. Thanks so much for playing along. I hope that you enjoy it as much as I did. Most of the reviews I’ve read have been negative. I’m working on mine today. I think that Immortal might be the straw that would break your TBR camel’s back. 😉

    • At 2008.10.15 06:08, Shana @ Literarily said:

      Excellent review, Jennifer. What you said is exactly how I felt about this book. I know a lot of people didn’t like the ending, but I did. I think I even shed a tear or two. It was just powerful to me.

      I really enjoyed discussing this w/ the group too. I am so glad you started the discussion up! I’ll try to get over there to post my review today.

      BTW, did reading about the Medecis make you as anxious for CW Gortner’s next book as it did me?
      Thanks, Shana! Actually, this book and The Other Queen has me all excited about Gortner’s next novel. Apparently, Catherine was Mary, Queen of Scots’ mother-in-law! Boy, if she had liked Mary, I wonder how that whole thing might have turned out differently.

      • At 2008.10.15 07:47, bermudaonion said:

        Thanks for the great review. I think I’ll skip this one.
        If you aren’t interested in the basic story lines, it’s probably for the best. This was an ambitious novel, no doubt about it. I will be watching her career.

        Read more from bermudaonion

        Review: Jake the Fake Keeps it Real

            Jake’s sister Lisa is a highly successful student at the Music and Art Academy –  a school for gifted kids – so it’s expected Jake will go there too.  He wins a[…]

        • At 2008.10.15 11:10, Marcia said:

          I, too, read this book for THW’s book group. I waffeled back and forth about whether I really enjoyed this book or not. I guess the telling part, in the end, is it must not have moved me too much because I didn’t write a review. I felt it keep going & going, just like Luca, and I wanted it to end. It’s interesting that flesh trade and brothel story line didn’t bother me nearly as much as it did others. I really got fed up with The Wanderer and the endless riddles and questions being ‘answered’ by questions.

          I’m looking forward to reading our next book whatever it may be.

          Read more from Marcia

          September 11, 2009 ~ 8 years today

          For those who lost their lives, for those who gave their lives unselfishly, for those who must move forward past the loss of loved ones ~ may whatever faith you believe in sustain you as you remember […]

          • At 2008.10.15 16:39, fyreflybooks said:

            I agree that while it felt too long and could have been cut down, I did want to know more about what Luca did when he was out of Florence.

            Read more from fyreflybooks

            February 2017 Wrap-Up: Books and Reviews

            Ye Grande Olde TBR(e) Challenge Update I started February with 213 unread books sitting around my house. And I ended with … *drumroll* …212! I feel kind of ridiculous continuing to put &#3[…]

            • At 2008.10.15 18:54, Darlene said:

              Great review Jennifer. You know I agree with you, I’m still not really sure how I felt about this book. I liked it, I didn’t. I know one thing-I did like Luca. Like you and Shana, I liked the ending also-I think I might of shed a tear or two also Shana. In the end, I’m not sorry I read it and I do look forward to our next selection.

              • At 2008.10.16 18:45, Karen H. said:

                Just stopping by to say hi. That’s a great review. I’ve got to add that book to the list.

                Read more from Karen H.

                Celebrating Pat Conroy

                Happy Birthday to the wonderful Pat Conroy. We miss you.I’m celebrating him today because he celebrated so many young writers like me.

                (Required, will not be published)

                %d bloggers like this: