#150 ~ Jane Austin Ruined My Life


Jane Austen Ruined My Life by Beth Pattillo

My Review

Emma Grant has been offered a mysterious opportunity to travel to England and research a huge lot of letters purportedly written by Jane Austen.  Conventional wisdom holds that Jane’s sister Charlotte destroyed these letters upon Jane’s request.  If these letters prove to be authentic, it would be a huge boon for her career as a college English professor specializing in Jane Austen.  Emma’s reasons for taking this trip aren’t purely professional.  In fact, this offer merely provides her with a plausible excuse to leave the United States.  Her marriage and her career are in the toilet. Basically, her life is a mess and she places the blame squarely at Austen’s feet.  Jane Austen, through her fiction, made her believe in such things as happy endings.  Had she not taken Austen “at her fiction,” she wouldn’t have been so blindsided by her philandering spouse.  She would never have given him as much power in her professional life, either.  In reality Emma is making this trip, for which she is draining her entire life  savings, to run away from her troubles while seeking revenge against her favorite author at the same time.

jane-austenJane Austen Ruined My Life is light and fun. There are references to Austen throughout, making me feel at home with Emma.  Although I did find the main character’s resentment of Jane Austen a little heavy handed, I think that Emma always knew that this attitude was a crutch. There was a lot of humor in Emma’s story and within her thoughts that reminded me a little of Bridget Jones’s Diary.  Intermixed with Emma’s personal drama is an interesting mystery surrounding the supposed letters written by Jane Austen.  I got a little caught up in the mystery myself, imagining what it would be like to be on the cusp such a discovery not only as a college English professor, but as the fan of a beloved author.  The ending was unconventional, and although I think I would have made different decisions, Emma’s choices were uniquely and authentically hers.  I think this would make a great beach read, especially if you can’t afford to pick up and head to London to visit the places where Jane Austen lived her life.

Literate Housewife & Christian Fiction

When Phenix & Phenix contacted me about this book, I jumped at the opportunity to read it.  The idea of blaming Jane Austen for ruining your life sounded fun and interesting.  I didn’t research the book or the author any further because, quite honestly, they had me with the title.  I don’t  normally read Christian fiction, so when I opened the package and noticed that the book was published by Guideposts, it knocked the wind out of my sails.  It’s not that I don’t think that Christian authors can write well or even tell a wonderful story.  I know that’s not true at all.  There are some many wonderful authors of all faiths throughout the ages.  I just don’t like to be preached to in my fiction – be that about religion, politics, philosophy, etc, and I find that modern Christian authors are not subtle in their evangelization.

To use a biblical phrase, I gird my loins in prepraation for reading a book that I believe will spend most of its energy beating me over the head with its message.  With Jane Austen Ruined My Life, this was completely unnecessary.  Had I not recognized the publisher, I wouldn’t have necessarily picked up on the author’s faith at all.  True, Emma’s father was a preacher and, in one phone call, he encouraged her to go to church, but that was just another parallel between Emma and Jane Austen.  Besides, what parent doesn’t nag an adult child about one thing or another?  While Emma is a moral character, I didn’t feel as though she made her decisions solely on the basis of morality. I didn’t pick up on any preconceived formula to lead her or anyone else back into the fold.  She grew a lot and learned a lot about herself over the course of her trip, but she didn’t have the great religious epiphany I was dreading.  If you havae similar views about Christian Fiction, I happily suggest that you give Jane Austen Ruined My Life a try.

Click here for a short biography about the author, Beth Pattillo.


To buy this novel, click here.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]


  • At 2009.03.25 12:48, Ti said:

    This cover reminds me a lot of Tethered. I’m just as surprised as you that this is Christian Fiction. I don’t read Christian Fiction for the reason you stated but if a good friend recommended a book to me that happened to be classified as Christion Fiction, then I would give it a shot.

    Ti’s last blog post..Waiting on Wednesday: Cemetery Dance
    I wonder how common “Bible beating” is in Christian fiction or if we’ve had a bad experience with an author who does? Either way, I recommend this book. A very enjoyable beach book type of read.

    • At 2009.03.25 13:43, WordLily said:

      Thanks for this review! Glad to hear of a Christian Fiction title that doesn’t beat people over the head. And yeah, the title’s pretty much enough on it’s own, isn’t it, when it comes to drawing a reader in? 🙂

      WordLily’s last blog post..Men and women read differently?

      I’m glad I’m not the only title slut. LOL!!

      Read more from WordLily

      FO Friday: Mittens for me

      Of course I finally got back to blogging at a time of year when most of my knits aren’t bloggable. Of course. But this project isn’t secret, hooray! I finished these mittens, for me, in Fe[…]

      • At 2009.03.25 14:26, Stephanie said:

        Great review. A book blogger was kind enough to send me their copy of the book. Now I just have to find the time to read it!

        Stephanie’s last blog post..Godmother (The Secret Cinderella Story)
        The good news is that this is a quick, fun read. I look forward to hearing what you think about it.

        Read more from Stephanie

        I’ve MOVED!

        It seems like a lot of people are taking the self-hosting new URL leap and I’m no exception. Please stop by http://www.stephanieswrittenword.com to check out my new digs (as an added bonus you get to […]

        • At 2009.03.25 20:33, Marcia said:

          Like you I don’t want to be preached to while I’m reading , or for that matter, any other time unless I’ve chosen the place and time for it. And as fate would have it both you and I posted along the same theme today though totally different story lines. I knew going in that my author was Christian based but I didn’t know where that would take me. As the theme of good and evil runs through many suspense thrillers and horror novels I was prepared for the worse and got the best. 🙂

          Marcia’s last blog post..Pondering the pages ~ BoneMan’s Daughters by Ted Dekker
          I am so glad that I read your review of Boneman’s Daughter because once again I requested it off of the briefest of glowing reviews.

          • At 2009.03.26 15:57, Nari said:

            I really enjoyed this book as well. I actually looked up Jane Austen landmarks to visit in London when I finally manage to fly overseas. I liked how unconventional the ending was, I thought it really fit with the changes Emma was experiencing throughout the book.

            Nari’s last blog post..BookTalking to the Middle Grades
            Unconventional endings in a romance are great if you ask me. Especially when they work for the character. I think that Emma showed that she learned from her experiences by the ending.

            Read more from Nari

            Books and Wellness

            I’ve been reading more and more about wellness. Wellness as in “drink more water, eat whole foods, avoid unprocessed foods and heal your body” type of wellness. I’m a relativel[…]

            • […] information on how this book and the rest of the Colette Trilogy came into being. I also reviewed Jane Austen Ruined My Life by Beth Pattillo.  I have written my review of Foreign Tongue by Vanina Marsot, but I decided to […]

              (Required, will not be published)

              %d bloggers like this: