#168 ~ The Firemaster’s Mistress


The Firemaster’s Mistress by Christie Dickason

Kate Peach, a young woman who was orphaned by the plague, has been forced to serve as Hugh Traynor’s kept woman and servant-girl in London to gain his protection so that she can use her glove making skills to make an income without being part of the guild.  Prior to her wretched existence under Hugh’s thumb, she was involved with Francis Quoant, a firemaster who left Kate alone in England when he went to work his gunpowder magic against the French.  Although he left her, she still feels fondly of him, especially given her current circumstance.  Hugh uses her past to get Kate to set up a meeting with Francis.  Soon after their reunion, their lives in London become too dangerous and Francis escorts Kate to his home, where his father, Boomer Quoant, still lives and works with gunpowder.  But are they really safe even so far away from King James‘ London? Will the specter of Hugh Traynor and Francis’ growing connection with a plot to kill the King and much of parliament result in their own deaths?

What appealed to me the most was that Catholic characters were portrayed as human beings.  Yes, they were flawed people, but not all of them felt that violence was the answer to return England to a Roman Catholic kingdom.  It must have been difficult in those days to have the way to practice one’s faith dictated to you by a revolving set of Tudor monarchs who alternated between Protestantism and Roman Catholicism.  Christie Dickason did a wonderful job of bringing that frustration to life in this novel.  England will forever be an example of how each individual should determine how or whether he or she worships, not the state. 

As a fan of Tudor related Historical Fiction, I was very excited to read this novel as it continues on where Queen Elizabeth I left off.  The British Catholics at that time were excited as well in hopes of being able to practice their faith in the open once again.  When King James proved to be a disappointment for the Catholics, a group of men decided to take matters in their own hands in order to bring a Catholic monarch back to the throne of England.  Thus the Gunpowder Plot was born.  Despite knowing the eventual outcome, I was certain that this novel would be a compelling read. Unfortunately, I didn’t find it to be so.  Once Francis and Kate left London, the story dragged for me.  The potential for drama was high with characters like Guy Fawkes in the mix, but it was very dry for me.  I finished this novel, but it took me nine days –  a very long time for me.  I am glad that I finished the novel, but I have no interest in reading The Principessa, the sequel.  

There are so many readers out there who loved The Firemaster’s Mistress.  While I can’t say with certainty that I would have enjoyed this novel more a year ago, I am currently a little Tudor burnout.  This could explain why I might have liked this novel a little more.  That is a side affect of devouring everything I can find in one time period nearly exclusively.  Here are some glowing reviews of The Firemaster’s Mistress by bloggers I trust.  They really talked the novel up when  I announced what the Historical Fiction Lovers Book Club was reading this novel in May.

Medieval Bookworm
My Round File
Ace and Hooser Blook
A Circle of Books
A Reader’s Journal
Peeking Between the Pages

You can browse  through this book for yourself if you’d like, courtesy of Harper Collins:



To buy this novel, click here.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]


  • At 2009.06.03 10:41, Lezlie said:

    Yup. Among regular readers of historical fiction “Tudor Burnout” should be a documented ailment. I’ll bet we’ve all shrugged off some really great books due to that very thing!! 🙂


    Lezlie’s last blog post..THE BORGIA BRIDE

    • At 2009.06.03 11:04, Meghan said:

      I’m suffering Tudor burnout as well, I really don’t think I could stand to read yet another novel set then. I think it’s a little frustrating that the industry churns out book after book set in the same time period just because it’s become interesting, but maybe my desire to read about the Tudor period will be renewed in a few years.

      It’s a shame you didn’t like this one more, but in this case I can see why.

      Meghan’s last blog post..Review: Undead and Unwelcome, MaryJanice Davidson

      • At 2009.06.03 11:16, Darlene said:

        Sorry you didn’t enjoy it more Jennifer, that’s too bad. I really did like it although it wasn’t one of my favorites. I hope you have something really good to delve into now!

        Darlene’s last blog post..Book Review: In Over Her Head by Judi Fennell

        • At 2009.06.03 11:25, Jen - Devourer of Books said:

          I got this from the library after Meghan’s review, but maybe I won’t make it my absolute top priority to get read before it is due. I can always take it out again later!

          Jen – Devourer of Books’s last blog post..When You Are Engulfed in Flames – Book Review

          Read more from Jen – Devourer of Books

          Linny’s Sweet Dreams List by Susan Schild

          Linny’s Sweet Dream List was one of the very first queries I got when started agenting. The writing sample had voice coming out its ears so I requested th[…]

          • At 2009.06.03 13:55, Tammy said:

            I read The Firemaster’s Mistress for the May selection for the Historical Fiction Lover’s Book Club. While it was a fairly quick read for me, and I did enjoy the subject matter, there was just something missing. I’ve still not been able to put my finger on it even though I finished it over two weeks ago. I found Kate and Francis to be engaging characters, and the history is certainly interesting. Some of the plotting was convoluted to me, so that may be my reservation. Like you, Jennifer, I don’t regret the time spent reading it but I probably won’t track down the sequel.

            • At 2009.06.03 14:42, Kathy said:

              I’m sorry this didn’t live up to your expectations.

              Kathy’s last blog post..Wondrous Words Wednesday

              Read more from Kathy

              Mailbox Monday

              Welcome to Mailbox Monday, a meme started by Marcia and now hosted on its own blog.  I found these goodies in my mailbox last week: Tuesday ASTRONAUT-AQUANAUT by Jennifer Swanson came from Media Mast[…]

              • At 2009.06.04 08:01, Violet said:

                I don’t think I’ve read any Tudor related book. But I’ve read good reviews of this book, sorry you didn’t like it more.

                Read more from Violet

                Blog change!

                Sorry have to change my blog mainly because It’s expensive paying to maintain complete control over the design. It’s not important or worth it to me anymore. Anyway my new blog is here&#82[…]

                • At 2009.06.04 13:09, used cars sioux falls said:

                  That was a really good review. I think I may pick it up anyway to read it.

                  • At 2009.06.04 14:38, Michele said:

                    I haven’t read this one and truth to be told, I didn’t even know it’s premise until reading your review here. I find the time period the author chose fascinating. We’ve all read about a bazillion books about Elizabeth and her parents, but not much is out there after Elizabeth. Thanks for the review…

                    Michele’s last blog post..A Worthy Collection for Your Permanent Library

                    • At 2009.06.04 15:48, lilly said:

                      I think I’ll go for this book. I am very intrigued by the whole ‘gunpowder plot’ and I actually haven’t read anything about it as of yet. Also I think I’d like to read something that doesn’t bash Catholics for a change ( I must say that at some point I just got tired of it and avoided novels that had anything to do with religion).

                      lilly’s last blog post..May Reads

                      (Required, will not be published)

                      %d bloggers like this: