#225 ~ Shanghai Girls

Shanghai Girls by Lisa See

tlc-logo-resizedToday it is my great pleasure to be Lisa See’s host on her TLC Book Tour for her novel, Shanghai Girls.  I would like to thank her publisher for sending me a review copy.  Please see the end of my review for a list of the blogs who are on this tour with me.

I have a lot of fun working as a tour host for TLC Book Tours.  They always have great books and authors on tour.  Check out their website for more information on this tour and the others that they are hosting.

My Review

Pearl and May are young women growing up at a time just after foot binding was banned and arranged marriages seemed to be heading in the same direction.  It was the 1930s in Shanghai, the Paris of the Orient. Pearl is oldest sister and college educated, but May has the love of her parents.  She is prettier, has a gorgeous complexion, and can seemingly get away with murder.  Pearl takes her role as being the oldest sister seriously and tries not to let her jealousy of May come between them.  They are not traditional Chinese women anyway.  They are out all night posing as Beautiful Girls.  Their painted  images used to sell anything and they live as if they own Shanghai.  They do until their father’s gambling debts force him to sell them into arranged marriages to a man whose sons lived in America.  At the same time, the Japanese attack Shanghai, shattering their hope completely.  They need to discover if they are more than simply Beautiful Girls, able to survive whatever fate life brings them.

Shanghai Girls is in equal parts a novel about Chinese life and immigration and the bond between sisters.  Just as in Snow Flower and the Secret Fan, Lisa See’s work brings Chinese history, particularly as it relates to women, to life.  In this novel, women have more freedom and options under the Republic than they had previously, at least for those women living in as cosmopolitan a place as Shanghai.  While these changes are for the good, they bring about additional stress within families.  This change in culture is so apparent in the opening scenes with Pearl, May, and their parents.  It was interesting to watch their attitudes and beliefs evolve with their life experiences.  Still, when you take away the Beautiful Girls, their heritage, and the environments in which they live, you are sisters.  They grew up in the same house with the same parents and they each notice anything and everything that is not the same.  Who has a sibling and doesn’t do that?  What I found exceptional about these particular sisters is how they loved each other so fiercely despite the jealousies and resentments that accumulate over time.  They each take their roles as older and younger sister every bit as seriously as their culture once dictated.

War makes up a great part of Shanghai Girls.  Pearl and May’s time as Beautiful Girls would have come to an end at the hands of the Japanese during World War II if it hadn’t been because of their father’s weaknesses.  This perspective of China under attack is something I haven’t read about before.  Even before the war, the scene with the girls stepping over a baby that had been left to die on the street was sickening.  When war broke out, it was that much more fascinating and horrific.  The fear and chaos came across so clearly in Pearl and May’s reactions to all that they witnessed and survived.  As this tied in to the girls’ experiences in Los Angeles as immigrants, I was reminded of Hotel on the Corner of Bitter and Sweet.  These novels would go together quite well if one wanted to explore the experiences of Chinese immigrants in the United States during WWII.

After reading Snow Flower and the Secret Fan, I bought Peony in Love very quickly.  I loved Snow Flower so much that I kept looking at my copy of Peony in Love with longing nearly every time I looked through my bookshelf.  I didn’t have to think very hard when I was asked to take part in this tour.  I wanted and needed the excuse to pick up another of Lisa See’s books.  I was not disappointed in the least.  Although there was much sorrow and darkness to this novel, I could not tear myself away.  There was one scene in particular between Pearl and her mother which will remain with me for a very long time.  It brought tears to my eyes and made me feel lucky to be alive, which is saying quite a lot under the circumstances.  I fully connected to this novel as a sister, a woman, and as a human being.  My only regret was not being able to make time with this book during the holidays in time to send questions to the author.  She remains one of my favorite modern authors.

Lisa See’s TLC Tour  Dates

You’ve read what I think about Shanghai Girls.  Why don’t you check out what other have and will be saying this month:

Monday, January 4th:  Suko’s Notebook
Wednesday, January 6th: Stephanie’s Written Word
Thursday, January 7th:  She is Too Fond of Books
Friday, January 8th:  Book Club Classics
Monday, January 11th:  Luxury Reading
Tuesday, January 12th:  Diary of an Eccentric
Wednesday, January 13th:  Peeking Between the Pages
Thursday, January 14th:  Caribousmom
Friday, January 15th:  The Book Faery Reviews
Monday, January 18th:  Booking Mama
Tuesday, January 19th:  Savvy Verse & Wit
Wednesday, January 20th:  Dolce Bellezza
Thursday, January 21st:  Book, Line, and Sinker
Friday, January 22nd:  Word Lily
Monday, January 25th:  The Brain Lair
Tuesday, January 26th:  A Lifetime of Books
Wednesday, January 27th:  The 3 R’s: Reading, ‘Riting, and Randomness

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]


  • At 2010.01.05 12:38, Susan said:

    Excellent review of a very memorable book!

    • At 2010.01.05 12:48, Melissa V. said:

      Great review. Shanghai Girls was my first read in the new year, and I thought it was a wonderful book. It was also my first Lisa See book..can’t wait to read more from her.

      • At 2010.01.05 12:54, Toni Gomez said:

        Fantastic Review. I read Snow Flower and The Secret of the Fan. It was so good. I didn’t realize that this novel was sort of post foot binding and thought it might be more of the same. I love sister themed books. Great stop on the tour. I am glad you enjoyed this.

        • At 2010.01.05 13:02, Jo-Jo said:

          I’m glad you liked this book. I loved, loved, LOVED it also! Peony is a totally different book, but if you enjoy this author I think you will appreciate that story also.

          • At 2010.01.05 13:37, Meghan said:

            I also love Lisa See’s books, and this was no exception. I’m so glad you felt the same way!

            • At 2010.01.05 14:48, The Kool-Aid Mom said:

              I have this as well, as Snow Flower and Peony, somewhere on Mt. TBR. I enjoyed reading your review, and remember all the reasons I picked it up.

              Read more from The Kool-Aid Mom

              Life, Gaming, Depression, Excercise, MARRIED! School…

              Well, if you thought I’d fallen off the face of the Earth, I didn’t. Life has been a bit busy for me. I got into playing World of Warcraft, for one. Then I got lazy about writing reviews, […]

              • At 2010.01.05 15:41, Sandy said:

                I’ve not read any books written by this author, but I did notice this book being on several top 10 lists for 2009. I really must give See a try.

                • At 2010.01.05 16:04, Lisa Munley said:

                  Jennifer! Great review! By the way, it is not too late to get questions to Ms. See, so if you still want to do that, just let me know. Thank you once again for always writing such engaging, wonderful reviews! I so appreciate all the time you put into reading and reviewing books for TLC.

                  I’m such a huge Lisa See fan.. I wish she’d write faster!! I think of the three, Snow Flower will always be my favorite, but I adored Shanghai Girls too. Peony in Love was wonderful but quite a bit different (a ghost story, really). Still great though!

                  Thanks again for all you do..

                  Read more from Lisa Munley

                  TLC Book Tours TOUR STOPS for September 25th – October 1st

                  Lie to Me by J. T. Ellison
                  Monday, September 25th: Snowdrop Dreams
                  Tuesday, September 26th: Read Love Blog
                  Tuesday, September 26th: Staircase Wit
                  Wednesday, September 27th: Becky on Books

                  • At 2010.01.05 17:51, Kathy R (Bermudaonion) said:

                    You’ve made me very anxious to read this. I’ve never read Lisa See’s work and now I want to drop everything and rectify that.

                    Read more from Kathy R (Bermudaonion)

                    Mailbox Monday

                    Welcome to Mailbox Monday, a meme started by Marcia and now hosted on its own blog.  I found these goodies in my mailbox last week: Wednesday MERRY AND BRIGHT by Debbie Macomber came from Penguin Ran[…]

                    • At 2010.01.05 19:55, Melody said:

                      Great review! I need to read her books soon!

                      Read more from Melody

                      Here and Gone by Haylen Beck

                      Crown/Archetype | June 2017 | 304 pgsSource: LibraryThe story opens with our protagonist, Audra Kinney, fleeing from her abusive husband as she takes their two children with her in a car. As they make[…]

                      • At 2010.01.05 22:16, Jennifer said:

                        Thanks for stopping by everyone. Those of us who loved the book are in good company. Those of you who haven’t should really pick it up. You won’t be disappointed at all!

                        Kool-Aid Mom – you have some gems in that Mt. TBR of yours! Get to mining it. LOL!

                        Lisa, I’ll be in touch about those questions. I’m so happy that I have the opportunity to ask her some of my questions.

                        • At 2010.01.05 22:36, Lisa said:

                          I’ve thought this sounded good but your review really makes me want to pick this up soon.

                          • At 2010.01.06 10:51, Beth Nolan Conners said:

                            I loved this book — actually I loved all of Lisa See’s books. I think she’s a fabulous writer!! “Peony in Love” is my favorite. Can’t wait for her next one! 🙂 -beth

                            Read more from Beth Nolan Conners

                            WAIT FOR THE RAIN by Maria Murnane

                            The very lovely Maria Murnane sent me an e-copy of her novel, WAIT FOR THE RAIN, along with her novel BRIDGES (reviewed here earlier). I chose to end my summer with it. This is a realistic but feel-go[…]

                            • At 2010.01.06 11:21, Michele said:

                              I’ve never read a Lisa See book, if you can believe that. She’s been on my list of have-to-read FOREVER but I just haven’t gotten there yet. Your review is wonderful and reminds me to bump her books up on the list!

                              • At 2010.01.06 20:39, Serena (Savvy Verse & Wit) said:

                                I’m looking forward to reading this one later this month.

                                Read more from Serena (Savvy Verse & Wit)

                                The Art of Drawing Dangles: Creating Decorative Letters and Art with Charms by Olivia A. Kneibler

                                Source: QuartoKnows Paperback, 144 pgs. I am an Amazon Affiliate The Art of Drawing Dangles: Creating Decorative Letters and Art with Charms by Olivia A. Kneibler has a colorful cover and it is clear […]

                                • At 2010.01.07 16:09, Marg said:

                                  I love Lisa See’s Historical Fiction, but for some reason I haven’t managed to read this one yet. I have borrowed it from the library a couple of times, but had to return it. Time to request it again I think.

                                  • At 2010.01.07 19:24, Lisa said:

                                    I have this one sitting on my bookshelf and I am really looking forward to reading it. Thanks for the great review!

                                    Stop by my website tomorrow for the Friday Puzzler!

                                    Read more from Lisa

                                    First Words

                                    “I had just come to accept that my life would be ordinary when extraordinary things began to happen.”
                                    Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children
                                    Ransom Riggs
                                    Copyright © 2008 – 2011 Li[…]

                                    • At 2010.01.07 20:41, Natalie said:

                                      I haven’t read this one but read a couple others by her and I love her style of writing.
                                      Great review!

                                      • At 2010.01.07 22:49, Anna said:

                                        I’m reading this one now, and I’m loving it so far. Glad to see you enjoyed it. I’ve heard nothing but good things about See’s writing.

                                        Read more from Anna

                                        Review & Giveaway: These Dreams by Nicole Clarkston

                                        She was adrift, without direction or inspiration. And for what? For the loss of something which had ever been hers? For envy of her beloved Jane, or disappointment over Lydia? A flash of anger rose in[…]

                                        • At 2010.01.10 19:22, Darlene said:

                                          Great review Jennifer. I finished this one a while ago for the tour and I just loved it.

                                          • At 2010.01.15 18:16, The Kool-Aid Mom said:

                                            Kool-Aid Mom – you have some gems in that Mt. TBR of yours! Get to mining it. LOL!

                                            LOL… I’m trying. It would seem, though, that this year I’ll have the schedule in a challenge for that. Maybe put it on top of the list for next yet? 😀

                                            Read more from The Kool-Aid Mom

                                            Life, Gaming, Depression, Excercise, MARRIED! School…

                                            Well, if you thought I’d fallen off the face of the Earth, I didn’t. Life has been a bit busy for me. I got into playing World of Warcraft, for one. Then I got lazy about writing reviews, […]

                                            • At 2010.01.17 10:08, bookworm said:

                                              I need to read this one. SnowFlower is one of my favorites. Great review!

                                              • […] Tuesday, January 5th:  The Literate Housewife Review […]

                                                (Required, will not be published)

                                                %d bloggers like this: