Quantcast

#242 ~ Twilight of Avalon

Twilight of Avalon: A Novel of Trystan & Isolde by Anna Elliot

Published by: Simon and Schuster

Published on: May 2009

Page Count: 448

Genre: Historical Fiction

Format: Review copy sent to me by the author

Availability: paperback and eBook

Giveaway: See the end of this review for more information


My Review

England is in upheaval.  It is still trying to recover from the double cross that ended with King Arthur’s death.  Constantine, Arthur’s heir, was just a boy when he became the High King and married to Isolde, the daughter of Arthur’s traitor.  Isolde is distraught when Con dies in a war with the Saxons and Lord Marche has planted himself and his troops in such a way as to be named the next High King. Isolde has reason to be suspicious of her husband’s death and has barely a friend in the world because of her father and her supposed  ties to witchcraft.  She tries to keep sane by tending to the wounded and dying troops, but even they distrust her because of her past.  She longs to save her country but, being a woman without the protection of a husband, faces more obstacles than she thinks she can withstand.  Could the connection she makes with one of the Saxon prisoners be the key to saving her country and herself?

I liked the following aspects about this novel:

  • You can tell by the writing that Anna Elliot is passionate about her characters and the subject matter.
  • Trystan was such a great character. His sense of honor and justice felt right for that time period.
  • The way that Isolde used caring for the wounded soldiers to take her mind off of her troubles and the troubles of England.  I also admired the way that she bore the combined burdens left to her by her father and her husband.
  • Brother Columba was hands down my favorite character.  I loved the simplicity that grew out of what was most likely a very tough and violent past.
  • Lord Marche was an interesting villain.  It’s interesting how men will be suspicious of a woman manipulating them in whatever means available to her, but readily take the snackiest of men at face value.
  • The cover is lovely, isn’t it?  It certainly sets the mood for the novel very well.

The following were issues for me:

  • Isolde was always getting the cold shivers.  I understood why, but it got old after a while.
  • Although she apparently did, I never really understood why or found it believable that Isolde loved Con.  Perhaps she loved what he meant to England, but I never got a sense of her love for him as a man.
  • The time period.  I can’t help it.  This story had all the elements that would normally interest me.  I am not sure what it is about this time and place.  This is by far my biggest complaint, but I really can’t fault the book for the time period in which it takes place.  It is what it is.

My Final Thoughts

Arthurian England just is not very interesting to me.  I kind of hit the same wall while reading Helen Hollick’s The Kingmaking.  This is a personal preference, though.  I never thought to set the book aside and not finish it.  As you will see in my Other Voices section, I am well in the minority here.  Readers loved this novel.

+++++++

This review is my first for Caribousmom’s Random Reading Challenge!  I found it to be a lot of fun to leave my next read up to the Random Number Generator on Random.org. I book down, 5 to go by August.  I wonder what the ol’ Random Number Generator will scare up for me next.

Giveaway

Twilight of Avalon is the first novel in Anna Elliot’s trilogy about Isolde and Trystan.  I would love to send my gently read copy of this novel to someone who loves this story or Arthurian England.  It just might be perfect timing, because Dark Moon of Avalon, the second book in this trilogy, is being published in May.  To enter this giveaway, tell me what your favorite novel is from this time period.  Leave your comment here by 11:59 PM EST.  I’ll announce the winner later that week.  Good luck!

Other Voices

Trish’s Reading Nook
S. Krishna’s Books
things mean a lot
Devourer of Books
Book Nut
Medieval Bookworm
Charlotte’s Library

16 Comments

  • At 2010.03.15 08:21, A Bookshelf Monstrosity said:

    I recently read a wonderful book from this time period called Here Lies Arthur by Philip Reeve. Thanks for the giveaway!

    fitz12383(at)hotmail(dot)com

    • At 2010.03.15 11:19, chelsea said:

      I really enjoyed Gawain and the Green Knight.
      Thanks for your offer.

      • At 2010.03.15 11:40, karenk said:

        i recently read ‘lady of milkweed manor’ by julie klassen…excellent !!!

        • At 2010.03.15 11:57, Jen - Devourer of Books said:

          No need to enter me since I already have this.

          I’m sad you didn’t enjoy this, because I loved it, but if you don’t like the time period, you don’t like the time period, I guess!

          Read more from Jen – Devourer of Books

          Linny’s Sweet Dreams List by Susan Schild

          HEY THERE. LOOK AT THIS BEAUTIFUL BOOK!
          Linny’s Sweet Dream List was one of the very first queries I got when started agenting. The writing sample had voice coming out its ears so I requested th[…]

          • At 2010.03.15 12:04, Lisa said:

            It sounds like there might be better versions of this same story out there. I signed up for 12 books for the Random Reading Challenge, which seemed perfectly do-able at the time. But I’m only on my 3rd book! I’ve got to get reading!

            • At 2010.03.15 13:34, bermudaonion (Kathy) said:

              For some odd reason, that time period doesn’t really interest me either – maybe I didn’t have a good history teacher or something. Don’t enter me.

              Read more from bermudaonion (Kathy)

              The Week in Review: 2.17.2017

              Between the Covers Finished last week: ALMOST HOME by Joan Bauer is the story of twelve year old Sugar Mae Cole and her mother.  After they lose their home, they head to Chicago to start over and Sug[…]

              • At 2010.03.15 22:40, Amy said:

                I actually haven’t read many (any?) books from this time period, but I’ve always been intrigued by this story. I’d love to have a chance to read it and learn something new.

                • At 2010.03.15 22:50, Nicole Mullings said:

                  I have on my bookshelf Mists of Avalon but it is yet to be read. I’m sure I have read something from this period I just can’t remember. It would be lovely to win.

                  • At 2010.03.15 23:36, Nicole said:

                    I believe Coffeehouse Angel is based on this time period, which I have recently read.

                    I would love to win Twilight of Avalon:)

                    nicole143_@hotmail.com

                    • At 2010.03.18 01:44, Veens said:

                      I have read nothing set in the Arthurian England. And I am scared that like you I might not like this or not find it interesting at all. Though I love the Tudors. I would love to give it a try anyway.

                      Enter me too! givingreadingachance AT gmail.com

                      • At 2010.03.19 10:04, Nicole said:

                        Do not forget me. I would still love to win. :)!!!

                        nicole143_@hotmail.com

                        • At 2010.03.19 10:53, S. Krishna said:

                          I really enjoyed this one, but your “shivers” comment had me cracking up!!

                          • At 2010.03.20 13:10, Patty said:

                            I love this time period…
                            Mists of Avalon was a particular favorite.
                            thank you

                            • At 2010.03.21 16:58, Elysium said:

                              I’d love to win this! Haven’t read anything from this era so I don’t have a favorite…

                              If this is international, please enter me!

                              crimson_haze(at)hotmail(dot)com

                              • At 2010.03.22 15:20, Judie said:

                                Have read Mists of Avalon, which I enjoyed. Most recently finished Kathrine by Anya Seton – a fantastic book. Please consider me entered.

                                Thanks,

                                jlmpanj AT yahoo DOT com

                                • […] Becky’s Book Reviews, Book Nut, Charlotte’s Library, Devourer of Books, Libri Touches, The Literate Housewife Review, Medieval Bookworm, A Reader’s Respite, S. Krishna’s Books, Things Mean a Lot, […]

                                  (Required)
                                  (Required, will not be published)

                                  %d bloggers like this: