#254 ~ The Brothers of Gwynedd (Pt 1) ~ Sunrise in the West

When Danielle from Sourcebooks announced her book club around the upcoming release of Edith Pargeter’s four novels about the first true Prince of Wales in one single edition, I jumped at the chance to take part of the four month discussion and to host one of the monthly discussions.  Given recent events, this might not have been the best decision I could have made.  Please keep my overall attitude about books in mind when reading what I have to say about Sunrise in the West, the first book in The Brothers of Gwynwedd quartet.   While some of my reservations would have been the same regardless, I know that my state of mind was a factor.

Sunrise in the West begins with the struggle between Llewelyn the Great’s two sons – the eldest illegitimate while the younger is born of marriage.  They are  fighting over who would take their father’s place.  This fight continues into the next generation.  Their fight against each other and England is narrated by Samson, the loyal servant to Llewelyn the younger.

I genuinely liked Samson, the narrator.  He is an honest, moral, and noble man.  He took the cards that were dealt to him and played them to the best of his ability.  The story of his birth and early life were interesting, but it seemed that they were told at a distance.  In fact, much of his narration felt that way.  It was as if he didn’t want anyone to get close to him at all.  Here he was in the middle of what must have been an exciting period in Welsh history and he discussed it almost clinically.  I am not sure if the author’s lengthy and rather passive sentences were the cause of this or simply exacerbated it.  Regardless, this lack of emotional involvement on Samson’s part made much of the novel feel as though nothing was happening when in reality the world was changing all around him.

When Samson became emotionally engaged there were flashes of the story that became compelling and easily readable.  As much as I hate to say that it took the advent of a love interest to catch my full attention, Cristin did just that.  I wished that the whole book could have been more like that chapter.

Overall, I found reading this first installment somewhat trying due to the author’s writing style.  As such, I ended up reading a chapter or less each night.  Sunrise in the West is clearly fiction, but it often read like a textbook.  I cannot say that I didn’t find the overall story interesting because I did.  Now that I’ve had some experience with Pargeter’s writing, I’m hoping that the upcoming installments will be more enjoyable to read.

If you are interested in finding out more about the book or see what others think, there is going to be an online chat about each section of the quartet hosted at a different blog. The discussion of Sunrise in the West will be hosted by Amy at Passages to the Past on Monday night, May 24 at 7pm EST.  You can alsocheck out what other people in Sourcebook’s summer book club had to say about their experiences of reading this part of the book.

May 17 Reviews

The Burton Review
The Bibliophilic Book Blog
A Reader’s Respite
History Undressed
Linda Banche Blog
A Hoyden’s Look at Literature
Renee’s Reads

May 18 Reviews

Between the Pages
The Broken Teepee
Books and Coffee
Book Girl of Mur-y-Castell
Tanzanite’s Shelf and Stuff
Passages to the Past
The Book Faery
A Girl Walks Into a Bookstore
Martha’s Bookshelf

May 19 Reviews

Beth Fish Reads
Deb’s Book Bag
Book Tumbling
A Work in Progress
Stiletto Storytime
Queen of Happy Endings

May 20 Reviews

Reading Adventures
Books Like Breathing
Kailana’s Written World
Confessions of a Muse in the Fog
Wendy’s Minding Spot
Mrs. Q Book Addict
The Life and Lies of a Flying Inanimate Object
Starting Fresh

May 21 Reviews

Loving Heart Mommy
Peeking Between the Pages
Celtic Lady’s Ramblings
One Literature Nut
The Book Tree
My Reading Room

May 23 Reviews

Carla Nayland’s Blog


  • At 2010.05.20 08:19, Marg said:

    I too am really hopeful that now I am used to her writing I will be able to go with a bit more in the second part.

    • At 2010.05.20 08:36, Jen-Girls Gone Reading said:

      I full heartily agree with your comments about author’s style. I just reviewed a book, Dust and Shadow, that sounds like it held the same initial interest for me that this book held for you. Dust and Shadow is the fictional story of Jack the Ripper and Sherlock Holmes-great premise right?? Bad delivery.

      I lost interest in all the long monologues and tiring sentences. I appreciate your admission about your “reading mood” recently, but tiring style is always tiring isn’t it?? And it always seems more so when we were excited to start the book and then get disappointed. Hope this helps…realizing you are not alone and that others are rooting for you! Thanks for all the wonderful posts!

      • At 2010.05.20 09:47, bermudaonion (Kathy) said:

        Hm, I’m not too interested in reading fiction that reads like a textbook. I’ll be following your progress on this one.

        Read more from bermudaonion (Kathy)

        The Week in Review: 12.15.2017

        Between the Covers Finished last week: Amy Tan‘s latest, WHERE THE PAST BEGINS is one of the most unique memoirs I’ve ever read.  Between stories of her childhood and her family’s p[…]

        • At 2010.05.20 20:15, Jennifer @ Mrs. Q: Book Addict said:

          I agree, it took me awhile to get into the book. The fact that the pages are literally long, made it for slow reading. I would read 2 pages, and think this is probably 3-4 in a regular trade paperback. When I was lost with all the characters, I did a bit of research online and that helped me. The great thing about historical fiction is you can find outside resources. Hope you like the second book more.

          • At 2010.05.21 03:41, Cassandra Jade said:

            Sounds a bit heavy going for me but the plot looks intriguing. Will probably hear about this one from others. Thanks for sharing.

            Read more from Cassandra Jade

            5 Motivations For Your Character to Cross the Road

            We all know our characters actions need to be guided by some sort of motivation. A character that simply reacts gets frustrating, and characters that have no logical consistency are usually unbelievab[…]

            • At 2010.05.22 02:03, Rebecca said:

              Thanks for the honest review! I have read many textbooks in my day and do a lot of nonfiction reading, but I don’t think I could hold interest in this particular time period if the story is not completely engaging.

              (Required, will not be published)

              %d bloggers like this: