#258 ~ The Song of Hannah

The Song of Hannah by Eva Etzioni-Halevy

Published by: Penguin Group

Published on: August 2005

Page Count: 304

Genre: Historical Fiction / Biblical Fiction

My Reading Format: Review copy sent to me by the author

Available Formats: Paperback, eBook

Challenge Fulfillment: This novel meets one of the criteria for the What’s in a Name? 3 challenge that I joined this year.  Click here for more information.

Synopsis from the Publisher

In the tradition of the international bestseller The Red Tent comes a beautiful, sexy novel featuring Hannah, one of the most well-known and beloved heroines of the Old Testament. Hannah and Pninah, once close childhood friends, become rivals for the attention of Elkanah, the man who has married them both. Pninah, passionate and independent, easily bears Elkanah many children, but bitter that he has taken her friend as a second wife, seeks fulfillment with her own secret lover. Hannah, the epitome of goodness and grace, remains completely devoted to her husband, but remains childless for many years, until a promise to God brings her the son she has yearned for. Despite their differences, these two women must learn to live together, protecting their own interests as well as each other’s, while sharing not only the love of their husband, but that of Hannah’s son Samuel, who will become one of the great prophets of the Jewish people.

My Review

When I read my first biblical novel by Eva Etzioni-Halev, The Triumph of Deborah, I was pleasantly surprised by how human the characters were an how much I grew to care for them. Deborah was such a strong and noble woman and the writing made me interested in a story in the Bible that I wouldn’t have otherwise given much thought.  While it took me about a year to pick up my second novel by the author, I was looking forward to that same experience.  In The Song of Hannah, I found that Etzioni-Halev’s writing is just as strong and compelling.  Her passion for the lives of biblical women is clear and easy to catch.  While Hannah’s story did not touch me in the same way, this novel held my interest throughout and shed light on the life of Samuel.

Unlike with Deborah, I didn’t really connect with or like Hannah.  She may very well have believed that she had a special purpose from God.  While it seems evident that the mother of Samuel did, how can you believe that God would want you to become the second wife of your best friend’s husband?  I never really “got” Elkanah’s draw for Hannah.  I never really cared for him that much, even though he did right by Pninah.  God may very well have a purpose for everyone and there may be special people called from among us to do incredible things.  Hannah and Elkanah felt more like God working around his people than through them.

Instead, it was Pninah who made this novel for me.  She found herself in one unenviable situation after the other.  Once she  stopped being the victim of Hannah’s destiny, she became stronger in her times of sorrow and humiliation. I wanted so much more for her and applauded her when she took her life in her hands and did what made her happy.   Whether she made the right choice, she took control over her life and relied on herself regardless of the consequences.

My Final Thoughts

Traditionally, Hannah is viewed as one of the Bible’s heroines.  What I liked the most about this novel, whether it was intended or not, was seeing behind a saint’s mask.  Pninah may not have been an actual historical person, but her story highlighted precisely the damage that can be caused to those around one who believes he or she is especially blessed by God.  That made this novel more interesting than if showed Hannah only in a righteous light.

Other Voices

I couldn’t find any other reviews of this novel by book bloggers.  If you’ve written a review, please contact me and I will add a link to your review here.


  • At 2010.06.07 08:10, Stephanie said:

    I have one of these books sitting around–it may be this one, not sure. I picked it up because I loved The Red Tent so much so I wanted to read more books based on women from the Bible. I really should get around to reading it!

    Read more from Stephanie

    Book Review: The Trespasser

    The Trespasser Tana French Viking 449 pages Synopsis: Antoinette Conway is fed up with being the low man on the totem pole of the Dublin Murder Squad. Treated by shit for being a woman on the squad co[…]

    • At 2010.06.07 09:25, S. Krishna said:

      Thanks for this review. I still need to read The Triumph of Deborah!

      • At 2010.06.07 09:27, Word Lily said:

        I’m definitely interested in reading this one, since it’s about my namesake. 🙂 I’ve really enjoyed most of biblical fiction I’ve read — particularly that by Francine Rivers — but I haven’t read this author before.

        Read more from Word Lily

        FO Friday: Mittens for me

        Of course I finally got back to blogging at a time of year when most of my knits aren’t bloggable. Of course. But this project isn’t secret, hooray! I finished these mittens, for me, in Fe[…]

        • At 2010.06.07 09:33, rhapsodyinbooks said:

          This sounds really good. I love that the author is doing this series on strong women in the Bible!

          Read more from rhapsodyinbooks

          Review of “By the Book” by Julia Sonneborn

          Note: Slight spoilers if you don’t know the story of Jane Austen’s Persuasion. Retellings are difficult. For one thing, fans of the original already know the story, so the plot arc is pred[…]

          • At 2010.06.07 09:47, McLaren said:

            I absolutely love this book! I love stories about women who lived during the biblical times. I’ve read “The Garden of Ruth” which follows from the story of Pninah’s grand-daughter, Osnath. But I believe Hannah and Pninah’s stories were way interesting than that of Ruth.

            You might also be interested to check on the Rashi’s Daughters’ series – with “Joheved” as the 1st book. It’s amazing how girl power worked during this chapter of our history.

            • At 2010.06.07 14:03, bermudaonion (Kathy) said:

              I’m glad you enjoyed this one, but I’m not sure it’s for me – I tend to shy away from Biblical fiction.

              Read more from bermudaonion (Kathy)

              Mailbox Monday

              Welcome to Mailbox Monday, a meme started by Marcia and now hosted on its own blog.  I found these goodies in my mailbox last week: Tuesday ASTRONAUT-AQUANAUT by Jennifer Swanson came from Media Mast[…]

              (Required, will not be published)

              %d bloggers like this: