#308 ~ On Beauty

On Beauty by Zadie Smith

Published by: Penguin

Published on: September 2005

Page Count: 464

Genre: Fiction/Literature

My Reading Format: audioboook rented from my local library

Audiobook Publisher: Penguin Audio

Audiobook Narrator: Peter Francis James

Audiobook Length: 10 hours

Available Formats: Hardcover, paperback, eBook, audiobook


My Review

I picked the audio copy of On Beauty on the suggestion of some wonderful Twitter buddies who answered my call for multi-cultural books with themes similar to Jonathon Franzen’s Freedom (which I’ll be starting in January). I’ve not read Zadie Smith before, which made this novel even more perfect to compare against Freedom. I’m a Franzen virgin as well. When I’ve finished them both, I’ll be writing a more in depth comparison of them both. I will still be reviewing them separately. The comparison has more to do with my #readingfreude than it does the novels themselves.

On Beauty, although primarily about the racially mixed Belsey family, is the tale of two black, educated, university families. The Belsey family is made up of white Englishman Howard, African American Kiki, and their three children, Jerome, Zora, and Levi. The Kipps family is made up of Monty, Carlene, and their children, Michael and Victoria. While the Belseys are politically and culturally very liberal and irreligious, the Kipps family are politically, culturally and religiously conservative. Both Howard and Monty teach and write about art. Even in the world of art they are diametrically opposed. In fact, Howard sees Monty as his arch nemesis. Despite every one’s intentions, it proved impossible to keep the families apart, even when they were separated by the Atlantic.

This is a difficult novel to pin down in just a few paragraphs. It’s dense and cerebral. I’ve spent months trying to write this review in my head and I’ve not been very successful. Instead of covering everything, I’ve decided to focus on the role of the wife in this novel. While outsiders might think Kiki’s lot in life was more free and appealing, she was locked down just as much as Carlene appeared to be in Monty’s home. The truth is that the women had more in common than anyone would have suspected. Carlene may outwardly hold up Monty’s ideals, her mind is her own. She doesn’t keep herself tied to an ideology at all costs. In the same way, Kiki finds that life is never as simple as black and white. The adult lives her son Jerome and daughter Zora start living mirrors how complex her own life has become. While the men in their lives fail to appreciate how their lives and view points can compliment each other, their wives are drawn to each other. They alone know how much their husbands are really alike.

Of all the characters, I related to and loved Kike the most. Kiki roared “I am woman!” in all her glory. She believed in herself and her culture when she was young and when she is middle aged, when she was fine and when she was fat. She grew more than any character in the book, finding that change does not equate to losing your essence. Her son, Levi, while less confident in who he was, was most like her. They both never tried to forget the importance of living in the here and now.

Since the demise of Guiding Light in September of 2009, it’s not very often any longer that I can say, ”He/She is/was on my show!”  On Beauty gave me such an opportunity.  It’s narrator, Peter Francis James, took a turn on Guiding Light.  I recognized his voice before I did his picture.  I found him to be a good narrator.  I think he captured the attitude and tone of Howard and Monty especially well.
Final Thoughts

On Beauty was probably the most tiring book I read in 2011.  It took a great deal of thought and concentration.  It’s one of those books I’m glad to have read but can’t say that I enjoyed the process.  I had to fight the urge to give it up because it was so stuffy.  That stuffiness is essential to the story.  Good Lord, it was so stifling there that things were bound to explode.  The explosion was more internal and introspective than spectacular.  It also required a good deal more of me as a reader.  I’ll be interested in seeing how it compares to Freedom.


6 Comments

  • At 2010.12.30 17:40, Melissa said:

    This was a fascinating book. It’s a modern day take on E.M. Forster’s Howards End and I loved comparing the two books after I finished both. It is complicated and dense, but I thought it was ultimately rewarding. Smith’s other novel, White Teeth, never fully came together for me in the same way.
    Side note: I’m currently listening to Simon Vance read David Copperfield and I finally understand your love of his work and voice. He’s perfect!

    • At 2010.12.30 18:05, Short Story Slore said:

      I used to be a huge GL fan when Danny and Michelle were on! Now I stick with General Hospital :) I actually really enjoyed her other book White Teeth. It was assigned in college, but I had to buzz through it so fast that I read it the year after I graduated and got so much out of it. The relationships between everyone were so intense. Looks like I’ll be reading this one when I have a lot of patience and want a heavy read.

      • At 2010.12.30 18:18, Carrie K. said:

        On Beauty was one of my favorite audiobooks of 2010 – it was definitely one that required an investment of time and thought, not an easy listen, but so worth it. I also listened to the Octavian Nothing books by M.T. Anderson, which Peter Francis James read as well – I love his voice.

        Read more from Carrie K.

        Book Review: Ex Libris: Confessions of a Common Reader by Anne Fadiman

        Title: Ex Libris: Confessions of a Common Reader
        Author: Anne Fadiman
        Genre: Non-fiction, essays
        Publisher: Farrar, Straus and Giroux
        Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
        Source: Print copy from my personal libra[...]

        • At 2010.12.30 22:32, Sandy said:

          Seriously, Jennifer, are you on speed these days or what? Holy crap you are cranking them out. Anyway. I’ve had this one on my to read list literally forever. I read about it in EW when it first came out. I am about halfway through Freedom on audio. I love the narrator – he has got it all going on. But I hate all the characters, just like I did with The Corrections. I still loved The Corrections, mind you. So we will see. I am a little bitchier now than I was back then.

          • At 2010.12.30 23:25, Jennifer said:

            LOL! I am not lucky enough to be on speed. I just wanted to get everything posted by the end of the year. There was a good part of the year when I wasn’t posting at all, so I’m playing catch up.

            • At 2011.01.02 06:58, Debby said:

              For a more detailed analysis of the baroque aesthtetic of Zadie Smith’s novel On Beauty, read Jérôme POINSOT’s article in MONTRAY KREYOL website[http://www.montraykreyol.org/spip.php?article4077].

              (Required)
              (Required, will not be published)