#442 ~ The Lifeboat

The Lifeboat by Charlotte Rogan

Published by: Little, Brown & Company

Published on: April 3, 2012

Page Count: 288

Genre: General Fiction

My Reading Format: Audiobook ARC sent to me by Hachette Audio for consideration.

Audiobook Published by: Hachette Audio

Narrator: Rebecca Gibel

Audiobook Length: 7 hours 47 minutes

Audiobook Sample: Thank you to Hachette Audio for providing this audio sample from The Lifeboat.

Available Formats: Hardcover, eBook, and Audiobook

My Review

A fire breaks out on the Empress Alexandra, an elegant ocean liner, and eventually sinks. Grace, a newly married woman, finds herself on one of the seemingly few lifeboats to escape the wreckage. Who she is, how she came to be on that lifeboat, and her role in the events that took place over the many days they were adrift at sea comes to the fore in waves of memory and accusation. When another person on the lifeboat is forcibly pushed overboard, Grace’s survival becomes about more than reaching dry land.

It wasn’t long into The Lifeboat when I became distrustful of Grace. I couldn’t believe that she was the innocent almost helpless woman she described herself to be. I spent the rest of the book trying to determine whether she believed herself to be this victim of circumstance or if she was actually  rather sly in laying out her case. She was, after all, on trial for murder. Typically, I love an unreliable narrator. Reading their story engages a part of my reader’s brain that isn’t reached otherwise. The Lifeboat is an exception. while I was never bored with Grace or her story, I never became invested in her future. She never became that innocent I wanted to defend nor did she ever take on a delicious shade of evil. Because of this, the question of whether she was who she claimed to be or if she was a selfish opportunist mattered little.

What The Lifeboat did very well was make me think. Grace is on trial for an alleged murder that took place in international waters. Who has jurisdiction over such a crime? Was it the country where the boat left port? The victim’s country of origin? The perpetrator’s? I took these questions to Twitter and learned that there  were trials in the United States resulting from the Titanic, so there was precedence for what happened in the book. I also wondered about the culpability of a person who has been trapped for so many days with complete strangers on a small vessel without sufficient water and food. Add to that the unmerciful sun beating down on you and lack of sleep, how responsible is anyone for what they do? How reliable are any of the witnesses? Thinking about these questions was an interesting exercise and I could see why Charlotte Rogan would be drawn to write this novel.

The lifeboat in this novel contains people from many different countries and circumstances. Rebecca Gibel did a good job giving voice to the main characters such as Mr. Hardie and Grace. For several of the lesser female characters, there was a change in tone when there wasn’t as much differentiation in accent. Most importantly, her reading gave the sensation of being on that boat along with the survivors. A good part of my enjoyment of this book came from her narration.

Many reviews and blurbs talk about how compelling this novel is, often calling it a page turner. This isn’t how I would characterize The Lifeboat, but it was still worth the read. I may not have connected with Grace as I would have hoped, but I very much enjoyed thinking about the questions it raised. If you decide to read this novel, I recommend choosing the audiobook. I think you’ll appreciate Rebecca Gibel’s narration as much as I did.




  • At 2012.07.20 10:17, JoAnn said:

    I’ve been on the fence with this one… will definitely listen if I do decide to read it. Thanks.

    • At 2012.07.20 12:25, Ti said:

      It was terribly slow when I read it. I really didn’t care for it at all.

      Read more from Ti

      Lake Bound

      My daughter and I leave this morning for Hume Lake! I will be bunking in a cabin with nine middle-school students. I am excited and nervous but I am really hoping for some quiet reflection and yes, a[…]

      • At 2012.07.20 12:45, Sandy said:

        This book was a bit of a yawn for me. I couldn’t care about the characters, I didn’t invest in the protagonist, and I wasn’t even all that thrilled with the narrator. It did raise interesting, discussable questions, but I couldn’t wait to get through it. I think everybody knows it is an unreliable narrator, so I guess I was waiting for more and there never really was. I am glad I listened though, just to say I did!

        • At 2012.07.20 13:38, bermudaonion(Kathy) said:

          It sounds like the narrator was the winning factor in this book.

          Read more from bermudaonion(Kathy)

          Review: The Paris Wife

          Once again, my book club motivated me to read a book that had been lingering on my shelves far too long.  The Paris Wife by Paula McLain was our selection for June.  It’s the story of Ernest H[…]

          • At 2012.07.21 11:22, Sheila (Book Journey) said:

            It is a thinker Jennifer, but I was not blown away by it. I listened to it on audio as well and just didnt really feel connected to anyone. I think you enjoyed it more than me 🙂

            Read more from Sheila (Book Journey)

            Audio Book Month: Let’s Talk About That Audio with Florinda

            Holy smoly….  I have dropped the ball on Audio Book Month.  SO many plans and then life has a way of keeping you running in other directions.  The good news?  I am not derailed so easy.  JU[…]

            • At 2012.07.23 09:01, Serena said:

              Sounds like a complex book, and I don’t mind unreliable narrators.

              Read more from Serena

              Jenny & Her Dog Both Fight Cancer by Jewel Kats, illustrated by Claudia Marie Lenart

              Source: Claudia Marie Lenart Paperback, 38 pgs. I am an Amazon Affiliate Jenny & Her Dog Both Fight Cancer by Jewel Kats, illustrated by Claudia Marie Lenart, may not have the happiest of endings,[…]

              • At 2012.07.23 20:37, Juju at Tales of Whimsy.com said:

                Great honest review. I don’t think this is something that would hold my attention but I appreciated your honest review. 🙂

                • At 2012.07.24 11:44, Caite said:

                  I have read some mixed reviews on this one…think I will hold off for now.

                  (Required, will not be published)

                  %d bloggers like this: