#445 ~ The Light Between Oceans

The Light Between Oceans by ML Stedman

Published by: Scribner

Published on: July 31, 2012

Page Count: 352

Genre: Fiction

My Reading Format: Review copy picked up at BEA

Available Formats: Hardcover, eBook, and Audiobook

My Review

Tom Sherbourne survived World War II physically, but he returns to Australia with deep emotional wounds. He takes work as a lighthouse keeper. The work suits him. It gives him purpose but is also solitary. When the keeper in charge of Janus Rock needs a temporary replacement, Tom takes the three month post. There he meets Isabel, the young woman who, much to his own surprise, will become his wife when the position on Janus becomes permanent. The two return to the solitary island to make their life. It was a life of heartache, however. Isabel suffers several miscarriages and finally a difficult still birth. Shortly thereafter, a boat washes up on the island. It is the cries of the infant that catch their attention. The man also on board is dead. Tom, a follower of rules and a man of precision, immediately wants to inform the authorities. Isabel, instantly taken with the baby, sees this event as divine intervention and fully intents to add the baby to their family. She names the child Lucy and Tom agrees raise the child as their own blood. Tom’s conscience barely survived the war. Can it survive starting a family on a lie?

The Light Between Oceans is one of the books I hoped to pick up at BEA this year. Lighthouses have always interested me and I have never read a book about a keeper’s life. Keeping a lighthouse up and running is a heavy responsibility. I cannot imagine having nine month assignments with little contact with others. Pair that with being a young wife experiencing the pain and despair of pregnancy loss, I knew that I had to read this book. There was a time when I felt I would ever become a mother, so I could understand what would lead a woman to take up a seemingly abandoned infant and let the world think this was the child for who she had waited so long. As an adoptive mother, I also know that without the conscious decision and blessing of my child’s first mother, I would never feel safe. This decsion had to take a toll on the Sherbournes. I was expecting it while I was hoping that they would simply be a happy family. I could relate to both Tom and Isabel. When the stress fully manifested itself, I was devastated and compelled to keep turning the pages.

ML Stedman has written a powerful novel about the power of guilt, regret, love, and doing what is right. I could feel the light of the sun on my face on Janus Rock and felt despair when Tom wondered whether Lucy, the child who fully captured his heart, would be better off without him. Tom’s deep need for redemption is particularly heartbreaking. This story is told so well. It will grab hold of you and make you think about what is important in life. This novel is sure to be among my favorite books this fall. I highly recommend The Light Between Oceans.


  • At 2012.07.30 08:21, Laura Kay said:

    I saw this book last week for the first time and read about it on the Barnes & Noble website and put it on my wishlist. I’m so excited to find your review and have it confirmed as a book I really want to get my hands on! Great review!

    • At 2012.07.30 09:32, Juju at Tales of Whimsy.com said:

      Wow. The more I hear about this, the more I want it. I for a time never thought I would get to be a mother either. Our daughter magically happened after four years of marriage. So reading this I think I could relate to both women. Great review.

      • At 2012.07.30 13:51, Audra said:

        Oooh, this sounds good — I adore the cover!

        Read more from Audra

        Wordless Wednesday, January 24

        I’m reading Susanna Kearsley’s The Firebird, and the decks featured are, from the left, Shamanic Healing Oracle and Ostara Tarot.Cold, wet Wednesday. Send cocoa.*****************************If you’re […]

        • At 2012.07.30 15:23, bermudaonion(Kathy) said:

          This sounds like a beautifully emotional book. I”m adding it to my wish list.

          Read more from bermudaonion(Kathy)

          Mailbox Monday

          Welcome to Mailbox Monday, a meme started by Marcia and now hosted on its own blog.  I found these goodies in my mailbox last week: Tuesday ASTRONAUT-AQUANAUT by Jennifer Swanson came from Media Mast[…]

          • At 2012.07.31 10:47, Beth Hoffman said:

            Your review really grabbed me! I’ll add this book to my list.

            • At 2012.07.31 13:23, Melissa said:

              I’ve seen this cover around and been so curious! Thanks for the review! Sounds like it may be a bit too heartbreaking for me though…

              • At 2012.08.01 09:10, Alex (Sleepless Reader) said:

                When I first saw this I immediately added it to my Pinterest Board with favorite book covers, but I think I’ll save reading it until the Fall. There’s just so much heartache and pain I can read about in the summer 😉

                Read more from Alex (Sleepless Reader)

                In the Woods by Tana French

                I’m not sure if this post is spoilerish or not. I’m not giving away anything on the crime resolution, but I have Thoughts on the way the book ends. Many reviews on Goodreads that aren&#821[…]

                • At 2012.08.01 14:59, SuziQoregon said:

                  Oh this sounds good! I hadn’t heard of this one until now. It’s been added to my list! Thanks.

                  Read more from SuziQoregon

                  It’s Monday What Are You Reading #97

                  It’s Monday What Are You Reading? is a weekly reading roundup is hosted by Kathryn at The Book Date.
                  This is technically a weekly meme but I don’t read fast enough to make that worthwhile […]

                  • At 2012.08.02 18:15, Ti said:

                    Got this one from Lib Thing and I can’t wait to read it. I have so many books to read right now though. Trying to read them by release date but it’s not working out for me.

                    Read more from Ti

                    Review: Start Without Me

                    Start Without Me By Joshua Max Feldman William Morrow & Company, 9780062668721, October 2017, 288pp. The Short of It: What happens when a recovering alcoholic returns home for Thanksgiving, only t[…]

                    (Required, will not be published)

                    %d bloggers like this: