Monday Mini ~ Bellman & Black by Diane Setterfield

MondayMini3Getting back into the swing of things each week is hard. So is finding the quiet time to write a review over the weekend. In order to ease out of the weekend, I’ve decided to begin my blogging week with a mini review.

As someone who loved the stuffings out of The Thirteenth Tale, I was excited to pick up this audiobook despite the less than glowing things I’d heard about it. I hate to give you a spoiler to my review here, but I’m glad I’ll always have The Thirteenth Tale.

Bellman & Black by Diane SetterfieldCover of Bellman and Black
Atria ~ October 10, 2013 ~ 337 pages
Simon & Schuster Audio ~ Jack Davenport ~ 9 hours and 40 minutes

When some of my most trusted book pushers told me that they couldn’t recommend Bellman & Black I wasn’t worried. Liking or not liking a book is a personal thing after all. Surely the book would work for me. I listened to the the audio sample on Audible’s website and grew even more certain that I’d enjoy the book. Jack Davenport has a fabulous British accent and listening to that little snippet excited me even more. The first few hours were equally pleasant. I loved the story of William Bellman’s early childhood and marriage. Usually when I like characters and tragedy strikes I am glued to the story. Here, that’s where it all fell apart for me. Somehow along the way I stopped caring. Davenport certainly did his best to breathe as much life as he could into the story and I would eagerly pick up another of his audiobooks. With him as company, I tried my best to soldier on, but not even Black could keep me awake. I didn’t care who he was (although I had my suspicions) or why he became part of William’s life. As Bellman & Black opened, I gave up the ghost myself. There was some excellent material here, but I found Setterfield’s execution lacking. Gothic novels can be many things, but boring isn’t one of them.


  • At 2014.02.24 12:11, Ti said:

    That’s how I felt when I read it in print. Just didn’t care about any of the characters. I wanted the author to do something with the daughter but that went nowhere. It wasn’t scary or spooky or suspenseful. It has not been said, but I bet this was an old novel she dusted off for publication.

    Read more from Ti

    Sunday Matters: Thanksgiving Prep

    Since Thanksgiving is my favorite holiday, I am normally pretty prepared for it by this time of the month but 2015 has been challenging for me in many ways and this month I am not ready. Yet. I have t[…]

    • At 2014.02.24 13:29, Kailana said:

      I am starting to think this may stay unread on my TBR! No one seems to have liked it!

      • At 2014.02.24 17:34, Sheila (Book JOurney) said:

        Great review of this one!

        Read more from Sheila (Book JOurney)

        Morning Meanderings…and then there were four

        A week ago I posted about a book club sort of thing that my aunt and I have connected over.   Basically it started as visiting and coffee but our conversation led to books and I have been feeding her[…]

        • At 2014.02.24 18:45, bermudaonion (Kathy) said:

          Yeah, my sister read this one and pretty much felt the same way.

          Read more from bermudaonion (Kathy)

          Review – Star Wars: Epic Yarns books

          The Star Wars: Epic Yarns books by twin brothers Jack and Holman Wang are just about the cutest books I’ve ever seen.  The Wang brothers have condensed three of the Star Wars movies into board […]

          • At 2014.02.25 12:47, tanya said:

            You have summed it up perfectly. I kept reading B&B because the writing was so good, but I kept waiting for something to happen.

            Read more from tanya

            Avenue of Mysteries by John Irving

            Reading John Irving is like seeing an old friend – there are tricks and troupes you know he’s going to bring out, you may roll your eyes or relished them with joy, but it’s comfortin[…]

            • At 2014.02.25 21:24, Grace said:

              I struggled on to the end, but yeah, my reaction was the same as yours. A shame you can’t judge a book by its cover, because I loved the cover!

              • At 2014.02.26 00:26, Jess - A Book Hoarder said:

                Such a bummer! I keep waiting for the one review to bring back my hope that there may be some reason for me to read this but I just don’t think it’s going to happen. :(

                Read more from Jess – A Book Hoarder

                Reading for RIP X

                I was really worried about how many books I would be able to read this Halloween season. This whole going-back-to-school things has totally cut into my reading game. But I have managed. Not only have […]

                (Required, will not be published)

                %d bloggers like this: