Quantcast

The Girl in the Spider’s Web by David Lagercrantz ~ Audiobook Review

Cover of The Girl in the Spider's Web

The Girl in the Spider’s Web: A Lisbeth Salander novel by David Lagercrantz

Published by: Knopf

Published on: September 1, 2015

Page Count: 416

Genre: Crime Fiction

My Reading Format: Audiobook purchased through Audible.

Audiobook Published by: Random House Audio

Narrator: Simon Vance

Audiobook Length: 13 hours 22 minutes

Available Formats: Hardcover, eBook, and Audiobook

Summary from the Publisher:

She is the girl with the dragon tattoo—a genius hacker and uncompromising misfit. He is a crusading journalist whose championing of the truth often brings him to the brink of prosecution.

Late one night, Blomkvist receives a phone call from a source claiming to have information vital to the United States. The source has been in contact with a young female superhacker—a hacker resembling someone Blomkvist knows all too well. The implications are staggering. Blomkvist, in desperate need of a scoop for Millennium, turns to Salander for help. She, as usual, has her own agenda. The secret they are both chasing is at the center of a tangled web of spies, cybercriminals, and governments around the world, and someone is prepared to kill to protect it . . .

My Review

I am a loyal reader. If I’ve loved a book you’ve published, I’ll read your next book. If I don’t like the second book as much, I’ll still read your third because of that first connection. I’m loyal in the other direction as well. I have loved Gone With the Wind since I was in high school. That book captured my imagination like none before it and to this day, a quarter of a century or just a tad more later, I often find myself contemplating the fate of Rhett and Scarlett. I love Margaret Mitchell until the end of time for that gift. So, when a sequel was announced written by some other author, I was scandalized. I refused to read it out of loyalty to both Mitchell and the world she created. I’ve yet to pick up any of the other spin off novels. If the story didn’t come from Mitchell’s pen, my imagination is as good as these other authors. It allows what happens next to transform as I experience more and more stages of life.

When a fourth book in Stieg Larsson’s Millennium series was first publicized, I felt the same way about some other author’s interpretation of the continuing story of Mikael Blomkvist and Lisbeth Salander. In fact, I compared Lisbeth to Scarlett in my review of The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo. Mikael and Lisbeth have become as sacred to me as Rhett and Scarlett. I had no intention whatsoever of reading what is now titled The Girl in the Spider’s Nest. No intention whatsoever until I found out that Simon Vance would be returning to narrate the fourth book in the series. That I love Simon Vance is no secret. What I had not realized until that moment was that my love of this audiobook narrator trumps my loyalty to the author. This is not to say that I didn’t waver at all before I started listening to the audiobook, but if this form of author disloyalty is wrong, I don’t want to be right. I simply couldn’t imagine Simon Vance continuing with Lisbeth without me.

Beginning The Girl in the Spider’s Web was like finally being able to slip on my favorite pair of gloves after a long, hot summer. I was there, again, in a cool Swedish autumn. As I was being introduced to the new players in this game, Vance’s narration brought an undeniable continuity between Larsson’s novels and this new one written by David Lagercrantz. Vance transitioned from one book to the other seamlessly, as if he finished narrating The Girl Who Kicked the Hornet’s Nest the day before. This was the series that began my love affair with audiobooks and that magic was still there. I was always happy to be reunited with my favorite Millennium series characters and enjoyed several of the new characters. My favorite new character was an American NSA agent. The tone and accent Vance chose for his character reminded me very much of one of my uncles. I could see him, through Vance, trying to bulldoze his way through Stockholm.

That the narration of this audiobook worked so well for me that it did two things for The Girl in the Spider’s Web: it kept me listening after my first “Lisbeth wouldn’t do that!” moment and it made it very apparent that it didn’t have me sitting on the edge of my seat the way the first three books did. As the book was drawing toward the climax, I noticed that almost every significant, action packed moment in the book was told in retrospect or from another character’s point of view. This kept me at a distance from the story and it took all of electricity out of what would have been an exciting end had it been experienced live with Lisbeth. That lack of connection or sense of immediacy as I listened made the story less fulfilling.

While the story wasn’t as satisfying an experience as it could have been, there was much that I did enjoy. An 8-year-old autistic boy named August plays a major role in this story and it brought a lot of heart to this series and the way that his situation impacted Lisbeth. It was there that she was most herself even as their relationship challenged her and made her grow. I will be interested to see how this experience shapes her as the series continues.

It must be a difficult task to follow in the footsteps of a deceased author who has created characters like Lisbeth and Mikael. Not only do you have to dream up a plot grandiose and unlikely enough to involve them (even in the first three books, I tried not to think too hard about that), but you have to remain true to readers’ perceptions about the characters. For me, the key to Lagercrantz’s success was Simon Vance. He was the bridge that brought me to the table and it was his innate ability to narrate that kept me there through a few early glitches. Should Lagercrantz continue writing Lisbeth Salander novels, I can only imagine them getting stronger. I plan on reading them, too, so long as they are narrated by Simon Vance.

12 Comments

  • At 2015.09.22 08:27, Karen White said:

    I love your writing in this post – you so eloquently describe your feelings about the series, and Simon, and I particularly love the image of slipping on the gloves after a long, hot, summer! But of course, I love your appreciation of the work of a master narrator like Simon!
    I got to chat with an author at the VA Festival of the Book who has been writing one of Robert Parker’s series after he died, and it was really interesting to hear his take, and how he protected his own writing voice while doing his best to respect what Parker had created. While continuing a series after an author’s death seems to be mostly about money, in some instances, perhaps it really is about keeping beloved characters alive…
    This was a good interview with the new author on NPR where he talks about his decision to take on the series. http://www.npr.org/2015/08/27/434916317/the-girl-who-outlived-her-creator-salander-returns-in-spiders-web

    Read more from Karen White

    Audiobooks.com #LoveAudiobooks Giveaway

    For my final #LoveAudiobooks 2017 post, I have a 6-month subscription to Audiobooks.com to give away. To be entered, just check out Audiobooks.com and then comment below sharing a little bit about you[…]

    • At 2015.09.22 09:08, Jennifer said:

      Thank you, Karen! I will listen to that interview. The title of the interview is very appropriate. It really is nice to know that Lisbeth lives on. She’s too stubborn to die.

      • At 2015.09.22 08:57, Kay said:

        I understand what you are saying here and I felt much the same myself. However, also knowing that Simon Vance was narrating, I’ve decided to take the plunge. And I also am keeping in mind that Larsson himself had more books planned for this series. It was not meant to be a trilogy. I’ve just finished a re-listen of the first 3 and soon will begin this new one. I appreciate what Karen said above about another author keeping the characters alive. Yes.

        • At 2015.09.22 09:10, Jennifer said:

          I toyed with the idea of relistening to the original trilogy, but didn’t do it. I’ll be really interested in your thoughts as you flow directly into Spider’s Web. I don’t know if Larsson would agree with the way it’s being done, but I’m sure he wanted Lisbeth to continue on. She’s too compelling and strong a character.

          • At 2015.09.22 09:57, Nise' said:

            I have much the same feelings as you did toward this book, and told myself to consider it if Simon narrated. I am still on the fence, but very glad to read your thoughts.

            • […] Housewife reviews The Girl in the Spider’s Web, by David Lagercrantz, narrated by Simon […]

              • At 2015.09.23 13:49, Michelle said:

                I am not a fan of this series, but my husband loves it. He is reading this fourth book right now, in fact. I am very curious what his response to the finished story is going to be.

                Read more from Michelle

                It’s Monday! What Are You Reading? – 26 June 2017

                Hosted by Kathryn from Book Date, this is a weekly event to share what we’ve read in the past week and what we hope to read, plus whatever else comes to mind. To learn more about each book, jus[…]

                • At 2015.09.25 13:04, Ti said:

                  I have mixed feelings about picking up this one. I want to, but I kind of don’t. I feel as if it will ruin my opinion of the series as a whole.

                  Read more from Ti

                  Sunday Matters: Seeing Green

                  We are in week 1 of Shrek the Musical so my time around here will be brief this week and next. Right Now: I am not working the show today AND my daughter’s cast is not in today’s show eith[…]

                  • […] Literate Housewife has an even better review on her site. I encourage you to check it […]

                    • At 2015.10.14 20:15, Samiam said:

                      At this point I’m boycotting it. When Larsson died, there was a huge custody battle over his intellectual property between his common law wife of 30 years and his estranged family. She had been a close collaborator, and had helped him with all four books. Larsson had disowned his parents and siblings for a number of years and didn’t display any intention of reconciling prior to his death. The Swedish courts awarded custody of the laptop with this book on it to the family, as Sweden doesn’t recognize common law marriage. I’m kind of holding out for a reversal.

                      • At 2015.10.16 07:51, Isha said:

                        Great review. Although I was a bit disappointed with it when compared to the first three books. Check out my review at https://explorerofbooks.wordpress.com/2015/10/14/lisbeth-salander-resurrected-book-review-of-the-girl-in-the-spiders-web-by-david-lagercrantz/

                        Read more from Isha

                        Movie Review: Arrival: A thinking man’s science fiction

                        What will you do if you can see your future? When you know the one thing that will give you immense happiness, will also cause you immense pain? Do you embrace the happiness or do you strive to change[…]

                        • […] The Girl in the Spider’s Web by David Lagercrantz ~ Audiobook Review (literatehousewife.com) […]

                          (Required)
                          (Required, will not be published)

                          %d bloggers like this: